SUNDAY B-B NOTES

THINKING ABOUT TONY SOPRANO

WOULD TONY SOPRANO HAVE BEEN A GOOD MLB MANAGER?

The Sopranos (1999–2007) is widely considered the most influential television drama ever made. Some say it’s the show that launched the modern era of prestige TV. I like to think that The Wire was as good, if not better, but that’s just me. James Gandolfini was brilliant as Tony Soprano, the antihero who was simultaneously monstrous and sympathetic, menacing and funny. He was a role model. Breaking Bad showrunner Vince Gilligan famously said, “Without Tony Soprano, there would be no Walter White.”

Before streaming, Sunday nights were appointment TV nights, as you would hunker down in front of the television to watch The Sopranos. Maybe that’s why I was thinking about the show as I put together today’s column.

Then I started wondering, “Would Tony have been a good MLB manager?” he certainly inspired loyalty, often through intimidation (think Leo Durocher) and respect (think Bobby Cox). He cultivated loyalty by making his players feel valued (think Terry Francona). Tony was very strategic and ruthless in his decision-making (think Richie Aprile), not unlike John McGraw, known as “Little Napoleon,” who focused on strategic, aggressive play to win at all costs. Or Tony LaRussa, who was always thinking on the bench. Of course, Tony had issues with impulse control. Yes, Billy Martin does come to mind. And he had some gambling issues. Hello, Pete Rose? Dealing with the media would have been fascinating. Tony was always careful with what he said and to whom.

So did I answer the question? No, I will admit I did not. There are many pros to this con and an equal number of cons to this pro. It is a fun one to ponder. Let me know your thoughts, I’ll even publish the good responses.

MANAGERIAL TRIVIA #1

What two managers share the record for the most World Championships?